John Green: Author of Paper Towns, An Abundance of Katherines and Looking for Alaska
An Abundance of Katherines Looking for Alaska Paper Towns anagrams famous last words Bio and Contact

BEDA 4: More Questions, More Answers

I had a beautiful drive today up through Mississippi and western Alabama, listening to Leonard Cohen sing, "I ache in the places where I used to play." I'm still a bit achey myself, but Tiny Chicken Disease will not keep me from your questions.

Q. Why YA?

A. I just find the audience more interesting than I find other audiences.


Q. Any advice for those who want to start a vlog?

A. Well, on some level my advice for vloggers is akin to my advice for writers. Watch a lot of vlogs; try to figure out what works for you as a viewer and why. And then, when making videos, try to remember that you aren't making them for yourself (or at least not only for yourself), and that you have a responsibility to engage your audience.

Also, I think it serves you well if you're not trying to get famous but are instead trying to reach out to people whom you respect and treat as peers. (I've stated this before, but will happily state again that wanting to be famous--while totally understandable--is a huge waste of time, and that it will never give you what you want, which is to fill up the empty spaces inside of you.)


Q. Why are all of your main characters only-children?

A. Well, all three of my novels so far have centered on peer relationships more than families. That's why.


Q. I have a friend who is a great writer and wants to be an author, but she says she doesn't want to major in creative writing in college because "so many great writers end up getting ruined by a bad professor." I think she's dead wrong. What do you think?

A. This reminded me of a great Flannery O'Connor story. Flannery was asked whether she felt that creative writing classes discouraged too many young writers. She replied, "I don't think they discourage enough of them."

Your friend will not be ruined by a bad professor. In my experience, professors are almost always right about a writers' weaknesses. (And if a writer thinks she has no weaknesses, she is mistaken.) I don't know of any writer ever who's been 'ruined' by a professor--frankly, I think that gives too much credit to professors.

That said, I don't think it's absolutely necessary to major in creative writing or anything. (I didn't, for instance.) Writing isn't like engineering: You don't have to present a degree in order to get work. Kurt Vonnegut studied mechanical engineering; William Carlos Williams studied medicine; David Foster Wallace double-majored in English and Philosophy; Eudora Welty went to business school. I think studying broadly is always good. (For more on this topic, read my favorite speech.)


Q. Nobody smokes to die. People smoke because of the immediate effect smoking has on their bodies.

A. I disagree, at least personally. I smoked for ten years, and in all that time I never once enjoyed the immediate effect that smoking has on the body. I suppose it's mildly physically pleasurable (slightly less than a cup of coffee, I'd say). Once you're addicted, there's a certain feeling of relaxation associated with smoking a cigarette, but the 'buzz' doesn't feel good so much as different (hence the analogy to coffee).

The questioner goes on to note that "Long term goals or effects are not nearly as strongly motivating as immediate goals or effects." This is true, of course, but there are plenty of bad short-term effects of smoking: it makes you cough, costs a lot of money, and (if you're a teenager) it's illegal.

If smokers are only interested in the feeling of a nicotine buzz, why didn't nicotine patches instantaneously end the smoking epidemic? They give you the exact same buzz, after all.


Q. Question: I'm currently working on query letters. Tips?

A. Don't go for cleverness. Just be straightforward and professional and make sure you're spelling the addressee's name correctly.


Q. I do have to say I disagree with your evaluation of the author being (almost!) irrelevant. Over the course of this year in school, I've learned that absolutely nothing an author does is unintentional.

A. Well, I'm not saying that metaphor is unintentional. I'm saying it doesn't matter whether it's unintentional.

41 Comments:

At April 04, 2009 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

I know you were an Obama fan during the campaigns, but has your opinion of him changed based on the decisions he's made since he's been in office?

 
At April 04, 2009 , Blogger Jen said...

So what *do* you recommend to fill up the empty spaces inside?

 
At April 04, 2009 , Blogger Melody said...

Thanks for answering my question! I'll pass on your words to my friend.

 
At April 04, 2009 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Some people start to smoke for fun, or because they're curious, or because they want to make their parents mad. And then become addicted and can't stop.

I remember the speech you did on 8/8/08 at CPL about Flannery O'Connor and young adults being discouraged about their writing and appreciated your response. Thanks for being encouraging.

My question is this... Since you insist that you weren't a good student in high school but ended up going to a great college, what advice do you have for smart college-bound young adults that did poorly in high school?

 
At April 04, 2009 , Anonymous Christine said...

Does anything fill up the empty spaces inside of you?

 
At April 04, 2009 , Blogger goreschy16 said...

I'm not going to ask a question today. Instead, I'm going to save all my words for Monday evening when MSU beats UNC.

One of these days I'll get a response out of you....
once of these days..

 
At April 04, 2009 , Blogger CalculatedPlans said...

Are you a synesthete?

 
At April 04, 2009 , Anonymous Summer said...

my friend Kevin refers to Flannery O'Connor as Flan-Dawg.

 
At April 04, 2009 , Blogger valerie2776 said...

Spelling jokes! Spelling jokes!

Do you enjoy the act of driving, in and of itself?

 
At April 04, 2009 , Blogger Allison said...

What do you think about Daylight Savings Time?

 
At April 04, 2009 , Blogger JP said...

If you had to choose one book to preserve, like the characters at the end of Fahrenheit 451, what book would you choose?

I'm really happy about your blogging this month, my last months of my first year of college will be much better because of your blogging!

-JP

 
At April 04, 2009 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Ah I didn't know you are a former smoker, interesting.

 
At April 05, 2009 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

So then did you smoke to die?

 
At April 05, 2009 , Blogger piepie said...

Do you have to go to college to be a good writer?

 
At April 05, 2009 , Anonymous Mike said...

If you had the chance to travel back in time to any single day in your lifetime, what day would you go to and would you change anything that happened?

 
At April 05, 2009 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

If you had the choice of having an entire year of happiness but not remember any of it afterwards, would you do it?

 
At April 05, 2009 , Blogger Jordon M. Birk said...

I'm trying to find level of inspiration necessary to relieve my brain crack, but the PDD prevails.
Of the three major projects in my head, one would require extensive research into the world of the future (or near-future, for that matter--taking place somewhere around 2065ish), another would require a lot of reading of every last detail about an ancient Greek character (postmodern existentialism, a bit like Stoppard's Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead and the other would require a level of maturity in looking at my life, retrospectively, which I just don't have (and then a fourth would be an immature sequel based on a supernatural ending to this one--but that's really more 10,000 pages of screenplay intended to take place over a few seasons on television). For your own ease, pretend that the preceding paragraph did not exist.

Do you have any special tactics to read faster and actually...you know...get stuff done?

And is that voice in my head telling me that I'm human scum and will fail at everything I ever try completely normal?

If I wake up tomorrow morning and it's supernaturally, say, 2001, wherein I'm 13-14 years old (yet I remember having been 21 the previous night in 2009), am I a pedophile for engaging in relationships with girls my same age?

 
At April 05, 2009 , Blogger Anila said...

My question is really hard to phrase, so I'm sorry if it's confusing.

I'd like to publish a book someday, because I think I'm pretty good at creative writing, but of course "wanting to publish a book someday" isn't going to pay the bills, so what other careers could I get into?

 
At April 05, 2009 , Blogger Katie said...

John Green, you are STILL arguing with kids about authorial intention! :-) Thanks again for straightening out my student who was obsessed with this same idea.

 
At April 05, 2009 , Anonymous Eric said...

I majored in Film Studies in college, so I may be asking you a loaded question, but do you feel the medium of novels is inherently better than the medium of film?

 
At April 05, 2009 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Where do you stand on the video games as a literary genre (in the same way, say, something like film or television is) debate?

Why are teenagers more interesting than other audiences? (and is it because their situation, at least in this country, is inherently transitory?)

Do you think behavioral androgyny would ever be possible in human society?

Do you answer questions from anonymous posters?

 
At April 05, 2009 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Have you ever met a fan that you didn't like/think was awesome?

 
At April 05, 2009 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Have you read the novel Ordinary People by Judith Guest? If so, what are your opinions on it?

 
At April 05, 2009 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

What ever happened to news Sunday?

Who are your favorite stand-up comedians?

How is Willie?

Which of your novels are you most proud?

 
At April 05, 2009 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

I smoked to die. When I was a tenn it was a small, destructive act I could engage in whenever I wanted, knowing I was damaging my body but in a more acceptable (and perhaps less likely to escalate) way than cutting. I had friends who did it for the same reason. I was fortunate to not get addicted, to be able to stop fairly easily, and I never felt any of the supposed short term good effects, such as getting a buzz. There may have been some things I enjoyed about the act of smoking, but I did it to die. Just because you (questioner alluded to in the blog) don't smoke to die, doesn't mean no one does.

 
At April 05, 2009 , Blogger Jules said...

Interested by your comments regarding fame, which I wrote some thoughts about in my BEDA entry for the day. If you have a minute that needs wasting, this can be found here, about halfway down.

Also, you might be interested in the following compound acronym, which I thought of the other day, only to find that somebody else beat me to the punch: DFTBEDA.

 
At April 05, 2009 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Yeah - did you smoke to die?

Also, would you recommend young writers gain some "life-experience" before trying to write anything?

 
At April 05, 2009 , Blogger Rachel said...

Why are boys so stupid?

 
At April 05, 2009 , Anonymous Kristina (not Horner) said...

Would you ever let your kids choose their own names like Alaska's parents did for her?

 
At April 05, 2009 , Anonymous Paige said...

What was your first pet?

 
At April 05, 2009 , Anonymous Starr_Stacey said...

Have you read any super-awesome books lately that you would like to recommend?

 
At April 05, 2009 , Blogger Grace Dow said...

I like JP's question. Please answer that one!!!

 
At April 05, 2009 , Blogger Unknown said...

Why is the website called sparks fly up? Did I miss something (I'm a new nerdfighter)?

 
At April 05, 2009 , Anonymous doublecrossed said...

Do you think names are an important aspect to your story? Do you think hard about them, or is it more on a whim, whatever sounds cool?

 
At April 05, 2009 , Blogger Catharine said...

Would you mind giving a quick list of generally good books to read, specifically for people who enjoy your books? I know this is probably a question you get constantly, but I've only heard you answer it on blogtv shows and I can never remember the answers or write them down fast enough.

 
At April 05, 2009 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

I've noticed you tend to have a lot to say on International politics, but stray away from more domestic issues (outside of Health Care, of course). Is there any particular reason for that?

I'm simply curious because I am a political science major (feel free to vote for me in 2024, by the way- we all know the United States needs a Nerdfighter President), and I love hearing people outside of the hyper-political universe I live in talk about politics. They have a very different perspectives, often times they're ones I overlook in my zealousness to be over-analytical.

Either way, I enjoy the political commentary you dish out. It's so much nicer to hear political thoughts expressed in a prosaic way, rather than the bullet-point-like discussion politics seems to have become.

DFTBA, my friend.
: )

 
At April 05, 2009 , Blogger whitneywriteslove said...

Will you please provide a link to this favorite speech you refer to?

 
At April 05, 2009 , Anonymous Ellen said...

What are the other five of your top 10 favorite YA novels?

 
At April 05, 2009 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

are you now or have you ever been chronically depressed? if so, what helps you?

 
At April 06, 2009 , Blogger Katy said...

John, when asked:

"Q. Any advice for those who want to start a vlog?"

the appropriate response is:

"A: Buy Alan Lastufka's book. http://tinyurl.com/youtubebook"

Then you may continue with your own advince.

 
At April 07, 2009 , Blogger Suburb Mouse said...

Have you heard that Jeffery Lewis song about Leonard Cohen? It's brilliant.

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home

website design by silas dilworth. weblog elements provided by blogger.