Faith and Science
(I wrote this post for YA for Obama and am crossposting it here.)
I don't talk about it very often, but I'm a religious person. In fact, before I became a writer, I wanted to be a minister. There is a certain branch of Christianity that has so effectively hijacked the word "Christian" that I feel uncomfortable sometimes using it to describe myself. But I am a Christian.
So I'm going to write this blog post as a Christian. I'm not going to write (yet) about the time I met Senator Obama. I'm not going to write (yet) about how Obama's economic plan offers our country the best opportunity to avoid what will be a long and painful period of economic stagnation no matter who becomes President. But I want to explain three reasons why I feel that I am called not only by my conscience and values but also by my faith to support Barack Obama.
First, there is the question of loving thy neighbor as yourself, which Jesus states clearly and irrevocably is the second most important law for his followers, behind only the love of God. Our healthcare system is profoundly broken because we have failed to live up to this high calling--because most Americans have been willing to live in a nation where tens of millions go uninsured. For all the uninsured (my brother Hank and his wife were among them for many years), bankruptcy is an accident or a diagnosis away. Money they've saved to send their kids to college must instead pay for chemotherapy, and not because they made poor choices or failed to work hard, but because they own or work for small businesses, or because they're unemployed, or because they've been sick before and so insurance companies refuse to cover them. (My father, a cancer survivor, couldn't get health insurance for fifteen years after his recurrence of bladder cancer.)
Making health insurance available to all isn't going to be easy, and it isn't going to run smoothly, and it will require sacrifice by all Americans. But I would have happily made the sacrifices involved for my brother or for my father, and so as a Christian I must be willing to make them for all my neighbors. John McCain and Sarah Palin have already said they will not bring meaningful reform to our health care system. Barack Obama, with the support of the U.S. Congress, will.
Secondly, the world in which we live. Apocalypticism has always been a part of Christianity. Early Christians (and some argue Jesus himself) were convinced the world as we know it would not survive for more than a generation or two. For much of recent history, this has meant for many Christians that we don't need to worry too much about what some Christians derisively call "the World." Evangelical leaders (and Governor Sarah Palin) have said that man can't possibly affect the climate, because God made it and humans could never destroy it. (To which I say: Um, okay, but didn't God make the passenger pigeon?) We are unquestionably called by the Bible to stewardship of the land, and right now that means Americans must make drastic changes in the way we use energy and how we find it. Our failure not to have done this earlier owes to the tremendously powerful oil lobby and an administration that has always protected them over the long-term interests of Americans (and in doing so, has financed a tyrannical regime in Saudi Arabia that has long denied religious freedom or the freedom of expression to its citizens). Climate change is the greatest issue of our time, and if we fail to recognize it, we will be remembered by whatever people remain as the prideful gluttons who said to future generations, "Let them eat cake."
Finally, science. Sarah Palin has repeatedly stated that she wishes to see creationism taught in our schools. I believe that every Christian (and indeed every American) should be opposed to this. What science has taught us does not invalidate religious faith, and to those evangelical Christians who believe otherwise, I would respectfully say that you are placing too much faith in the power of science. Not that science isn't powerful: We now know, thanks to rational thought and the testing of hypotheses, that evolution was the driving force behind the breathtaking diversity of life in the world. And we know that the earth has existed far longer than we have. Science has given so much to the experience of being a creature on this planet. But it does not render our spiritual lives irrelevant.
The anti-intellecutalism that has become the hallmark of religious conservatism in contemporary Christianity (and many other religions) will only set us back--not only economically and politically but also spiritually. We must invest in science; we must teach our children the scientific method; we must share with them the myriad discoveries that the scientific method has brought us. And we must do all of these things in classrooms that are in the business of teaching children how to learn, and not in the business of teaching that faith in God is incompatible with the intellectual rigor and creative innovation that have been the glory of our nation's past. Christianity loses in that bargain, and so, too, does America.
62 Comments:
amazing. way to pwn the people that twist religion in their own sick ways.
Thanks for this post John. I am not an American. But I am a Christian, and even though we don't have the conservative Christian right here in New Zealand, I am still judged, people still decide that I hold beliefs that I do not hold at all.
And although officially, NZ and the USA have not been allies since the 1980s and that whole nuclear thing, I am proud to call Americans my neighbours.
My media studies paper asks us to investigate coverage of our election or of yours. Most people I know are far more interested in the outcome of your elections. So I'm watching (not in a creepy way) ... and I'm hoping. And I'm praying.
Excellently put, John.
I usually avoid mentioning my beliefs because as a Christian who recognizes evolution and opposes teaching creationism, it often seems I am caught between two supposedly conflicting views.
Thank you so much for sharing.
Looking forward to Lancaster.
I lack what I'll call the "cognitive restraint" necessary to believe in Christianity or, for that matter, Judaism (the faith that was ineffectively bequeathed from my mother). I am a born over-thinker.
As for Obama, it's more than just Abrahamic faiths that support progressive politics and human action: it's also the Eastern wisdom--wisdom that is almost never if not never against science--that I've studied independently in effort to fill in the blanks that exist in a life without faith, without love. The Buddha Gautama believed in helping others. His wisdom became more emphasized in the Tibetan Vajrayana tradition of Buddhism--The Dalai Lama as emphasis of this. Jainism perhaps the most--with the underlying philosophy that all living things (okay...all members of the animal kingdom) have a soul, a Jiva, and that it is our duty to be civil to every Jiva out there.
*Applauds*
Thank you John, for this amazing post. I am also a Christian, and I will also be voting for Barack Obama in a few weeks. It's been a challenge, being an Obama supporter, when so many of my friends and family members support McCain. I'm a woman of few words, so I've found it hard to find the right words to express just why I support Obama. You've said everything perfectly here. Thank you!
Im not suite sure how to write this since nothing seems to be coming out right. But thank you. That was spot on with how I look at this election and the world in general. = D
It's nice to see a religious viewpoint from the democratic side. Everything you said just made sense... I can't think of what else to say... you sure do have a way with words. thanks for this.
As a fellow Christian, thanks for reaffirming that science, higher thought, and a strong belief in God can coexist. I'm encouraged by the fact that someone as talented and intellectual as you are is willing to divulge his faith. It's nice to know that there's moderation to be found between atheism and close-minded Christianity.
Interesting post. For someone, like me, who is both a Christian and a fan of scientific discovery, it's a tough time to live in the US.
One thing I would like to state, though--when a certain group of Christians talk about "the world," they're not usually talking about Mother Earth itself. It's more of a concept that means things that are not of God. Values and concerns that non-Christian people indulge in that Christians are told not to (via Biblical teachings).
There are also a lot of Evangelical Christians who believe in acting as stewards of this planet, in taking care of God's creations and not wasting what He's given us. I don't belong to any particular denomination, but my father and grandfather are both Evangelical ministers. Not all of them are bad. ;)
Thank you for posting this!
Amen. Well done!
This comment has been removed by the author.
wow, John, thank you for this post! I have a lot I'd like to say about the issue of Christianity and polotics, but I'm not going to put it in a comment. Do you mind if I sent you an email about my thoughts on this matter?
-Hannah
*wild applause*
This comment has been removed by the author.
Well said, sir! What annoys me the most is people equate Christianity with voting Republican. As if somehow my faith is not as strong because I am also a Democrat.
I'm so glad you found your calling as a writer. People like me rely on like-minded people (in this case, you) who can eloquently express their thoughts so we can use them to help convey our own. Which basically means I'm going to copy this link and post it to Facebook. Or something like that. ;)
i'm not a christian. but that was one of the few things i've ever read from a christian point of view that i agreed with.
thanks.
Some very interesting points. I like reading things that make me thing. A thought I had was love thy neighbor goes past our borders obviously. Couldn't an argument be made that our system of medical care (grounded in capitalism) has saved many more lives around the world than if it didn't exist. Most (if not all) medical companies exist to make money. They make money by creating medical products/procedures that save people's lives. If you take the money making aspect away from medicine less advancement will take place. The world has largely rellied on medical advancements in the US to improve their medical care. Without our capital system of medicine less advancement would have occured throughout the years. This would have caused more people to die. So aren't we already loving our (worldwide) neighbors...
So...quick question. How will getting the gov't involved in health care help anything? I don't want to be pernicious, but anything the gov't has gotten involved in private affairs, it has screwed things up. Royally. I agree with you that we've failed our calling to love our neighbors. But I don't understand how the gov't could help. Care to illuminate? Thank you!
Sarah Palin makes me so mad. she is the exact opposite of everything I believe in.
but anyway.
if it weren't for you, I would know (and care) way less about politics than I do now.
yay!
Nicely put. Calm, rational, passionate. More thoughtfulness is needed in this election. Unfortunately, the system is not in favor of such thoughtfulness. But I'm glad you are sharing. It is important and you do have an audience who will listen. So keep sharing and hopefully people will be thoughtful when it comes time to cast their vote.
Thank you, John. I, too, am glad to see someone asserting religion as being compatible with being a Democrat (even though that wasn't your main point).
To the person who wondered about capitalism and medical advances - consider this: as long as medicine is run for financial gain more than helping people, you will find that technologies and medications will exist to help people cope and manage with things (so that you can sell more and more pills) rather than to cure them. Both are important, but I would like to see more emphasis on cures than there are now. Also there would be more room for treatment other than medication, possibly more emphasis on healthy living and habits, since they're not trying to sell sell sell.
I'm not saying that this is guaranteed TO happen, but that with our system the way it currently is, it is guaranteed NOT to happen.
The US has helped many other countries medically because we have put a lot of money into R&D. Imagine what it could be like if the medical industry didn't also have to pay multi-million dollar salaries to CEO's. Imagine what it could be like if the people running things were interested more than anything in helping mankind.
There are many examples of other countries that have done a good job of creating nation-wide health care, and I hope that ours will look to them for an example rather than make some sort of bandaid that will mostly be geared towards pacifying the current industry when they whine about the changes.
I don't want to be the radical here, but one of the other basic facets of the Bible is the command not to murder and to protect the innocent. Sorry to bring abortion into this, but Barack Obama is an avid supporter of later-term abortion through induced labor. However, this intitles that if the premature baby does not die in the procedure-and almost 20% don't-they are simply abandoned and do not get the medical care any baby deserves. Simply put, they are abandoned; stuck in a room and left to die. Now I know I'm sticking my neck out here, but no medical attention? The least you could do would be to feed them, and send them to an adoption agency. Barack Obama says he supports this because in the case of his daughters, he wouldn't want them to be "punished" with the burden of a baby. This man supports the killing of BORN, unclaimed babies. And oh fyi, even Hilary Clinton voted against this one.
Ok, I'm done...sorry if I offended anyone. :) And John, I really do respect you and I appreciate how well you present your opinons to us.
I agree about health insurance. My mom loses depending on how much she makes a month and as a part time waitress... it varies. She has been in a few car accidents that have messed up her back. The day before she was going to get a back MRI, she got a letter saying that they would longer insure her.
I have hypogammaglobulinemia(B-cell disorder/ antibody deficiency) and Pseudotumor Cerebri(Swelling of the brain caused by high CFS). I have twenty medicine that I take to feel normal. I average 4 surgeries a year. I have to get Lumbar Punctures to lower the risk of vision lost and my headaches. I get blood infusion of IGg, every 3 weeks. I am 17 and still go to Seattle Children's, because that is the only place near my house that deals with what I have. When I turn 18, I will most likely lose my insurance. Since they have declared 5 times in the past year and 9 months... that I am insuranceless.
Worrying about this now, is I guess a part of my life. I am just grateful that it started at 15 instead of 5.
Sorry for the rant, I was at the hospital today and came home to about 10 bills each with about $60 co-pays.
I believe in both Evolution and Creatism. If someone doesn't, believe in evolution, have them explain why we have differnt flu shots each year.
For me, it is going to be the debates, in order to decide who to vote. I think both canidates are ready... I am just not sure who to support. I am socially... pretty liberal, and almost anything else... I am conservative/moderate.
Hope you have a nice day.
Sarah.
Thank you, John, for posting this. It is refreshing to read religion and politics together sensibly.
Reading your post from a neither/nor perspective, though, I must ask--do you think that politics could function smoother if we openly took note of the presence of the Inalienable Rights in all belief systems? Or should Church and State remain as seperate as possible?
I'm not a Christian for a number of reasons, but I am very interested in religious opinions... I love the points you made in this. You're entirely right. Thank you for writing this.
John, as a Christian and a Nerdfighter I just want to say....
THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU
It is SO refreshing to know that there are Christians out there that understand that science and religion don't have to be oppositional.
Seriously, I want to hug you right now. =3
Oh, and while I am glad that you are a writer, you would have made a kickass minister.
The Yeti is a lucky woman.
Um, I think using the command to love your neighbor as yourself to support Obama's health care reform movement is kind of a stretch. I'm not saying it doesn't apply, but it could kind of apply to everything. So that's kind of weak.
I don't want to attack your faith, but your post actually made me scratch my head a little. The Bible says that the world was created in six twenty-four hour days. God in his almighty power created the world with age. Science and Christianity don't have to oppose each other, but I don't understand why any Christian would oppose creationism when according to the Bible it is the truth.
I'm also very glad someone brought up abortion. Abortion is murder and is contrary to what the Bible teaches. Many of Obama's social stances are. I wish we could sit down and talk about religion, John. There are many things I could say...but I have to study. Stupid college.
I don't understand politics...(especially economics, but that's mostly because I'm pretty much mathematicallty retarded) and I don't even pretend to, because all I hear is mudslinging and circular logic and mostly just.. crap.
But I do completely and totally understand what you mean about the word "Christian" being hijacked. I too kind of avoid discussing my faith because I am usually attacked for it (albeit most often by those who have no idea what they're talking about anyway..)
I'm still trying to figure the whole 'who to vote for and why' thing....
See you in Lancaster!
-M.K.
Well said John. In my, um, professional life, I am consistently the odd man out in the political arena where my colleagues are convinced that people have faith have only one choice in this election. It extends to my adopted country where the Conservative party has become the party of evangelical Christians and a vote for anyone else questions your own faith in Jesus.
Thanks for being a community organizer...
This is just great. I've been looking for ways to express to my mom and step dad that Obama is, in my words, better. They scare me saying they want to vote for McCain. My point, both of them know I love you for your intellect, so they'll listen. You've made really good points.
Although I'm not Christian by any means, I still agree with you.. And thats the first, EVER. (to agree with a christian- I'm really hard headed when it comes to religion)
I don't know about the science thing, it would be neat to learn more about science.. (but I hate science, it can just be interesting) AND this doesn't mean I don't like Sarah P.. I actually dislike her ALOT, how dare she try to ban books!
Your great. Can't wait to see you on the 2nd in OKC.
DFTBA
I completely agree with you on the issues here. I, too, am a Christian - mostly a conservative one - and I'm voting for Barack Obama. I disagree with him on the issues of abortion and same-sex marriage, but I don't believe I should base my choice on only those two issues, which is what many conservative Christians do. It is very unfortunate that many Christians are ignorant and/or apathetic on many issues.
Wow, John, thanks for posting this. I feel pretty much the exact same way, and I get irritated with some Christians who tell me that I'm not a "true" Christian if I believe in evolution, or some other stupid thing. I believe that the Bible shouldn't be interpreted as literally as some want it to. After all, why couldn't God be the one behind evolution? I feel like he is. Certainly the enormous amount of mutations that led to the present diversity on earth would have been guided by a divine being. Things like that bother me, which is why I liked your post :)
As someone raised in a Christian church, though currently unaffiliated, I am with you all the way, John. I would point out that anti-intellectualism is nothing new in this country. I, for one, think it's about time that sad tradition stopped. We're going to need all the brain power and the openness to new ideas that we can get if we are going to get out of the mess we are currently in.
John, you have just completely opened my eyes to look at the upcoming election from a new perspective. I may not be a practicing Christian but I was raised in the church and completely agree with the subjects you presented in this blog. Have you ever thought of writing a book about contemporary politics and religion, because I think you would be amazing at that.
Amazingly put! I really enjoy reading your blogs! Thanks so much for your insight.
-Kristina
P.S. Im studying abroad in London right now and jut wanted to let you know I still pre-ordered on Amazon and will be getting Paper Towns !! Actually, two copies!!
Thanks for the post, John! :) I'm a Baha'i, not a Christian, but my beliefs are pretty much parallel to all those you have stated. The need for both science AND religion - that one is useless without the other - is pretty rare, at least where I live. It's hard to be openly religious and yet believe in evolution when you live, as I do, in a town of evangelical fundamentalism; a lot of people have trouble differentiating between those who believe in God and those who believe in God-That-Loves-America-More-Than-Any-Other-Country.
Thank you, John, for this thoughtful and well-considered post. As an evangelical Christian who supports Barack Obama, the world can seem like a pretty lonely place at times, and it is good to read my own convictions expressed so eloquently. I have decided in that in this election, I can no longer ignore what were so obviously the priorities of Jesus.
Take great heart! You are following in the footsteps of other men of God such as Jim Wallis, Randall Balmer, and Frank Schaeffer.
May God richly bless you!
As a fellow Christian, I'm appreciative of your position as well John. And as usual it is thoughtful and well written. (I will note however that Palin is an advocate for intelligent design not creationism. There is a difference)
I too am living without health insurance. And I am also passionate about the environment. I wish I could vote primarily on these issues. But I can't. Obama is more pro-choice than NARAL. And we've lost the equivalent of the population of the state of California since Roe V Wade. Abortion is responsible for more african american deaths each year than any single disease.
It absolutely galls me that I rarely can vote on other issues I'm passionate about. But environment, health insurance and economics must be subordinate to life itself.
haha....good one with the carrier pigeon line. Being a Christian I do agree with you to some extent. As a Christian myself, while I do not think the earth will be destroyed until God wants it to be, that doesn't mean we should trash it. The Bible preaches good stewardship of the earth, you are right, and we should do thus. God intrusted the earth to us, and thus far we are doing a pitiful job of taking care of it. The earth is a gift from God, so shouldn't we treat it with respect, and take care of that gift? You wouldn't just carelessly wreck a shiny new car that someone gave you. You would take care of the gift.
As for the idea about creationism vs. evolution in schools, I think both should be taught (and maybe whatever viewpoint is out there) so that students can make their own decision about this. I was homeschooled, and I learned both viewpoints in my schooling. Too often students are spoonfed information and not given to tools to allow them to think for themselves.
nicely said john. nicely said.
--brittany
Wow. That's the best pro-Obama/Christian post I've ever read.
I, myself tend to agree with the Republican party on most issues. However, I can definitely agree that (1) more needs to be done about health care and (2) some Christians need to take a little more stock in how they treat the environment. Although, I haven't run across any ministers in my area who think that the environment isn't important. >.>
Anywho, I'm not sure about the creationism bit. I mean, I think that evolution should be taught, but I think the "other side of the argument" is worth mentioning as well. Evolution has never really been pushed in my school, but neither has creationism. (Thus, I feel quite ill-informed on the subject.
I would love to see more blogs from you, John, from a Christian aspect. It certainly makes me feel less alone as a Nerdfighter. :3
A memory from freshman year in high school comes to mind. The roughly 66 other people I went to school with for my K-12 private and Catholic education all had a logical bone to pick with creationism. It started when a home-schooled girl joined our class in freshman year and was asked in science class how the earth was made. She responded with the typical, "God made the world and everything on it in seven days." I remember staring at her as if she were crazy, and then one of my classmates going, "You do know there are two completely different creation stories in the bible, right?"
I admit I found it funny, but now I just feel pity for those people who can't or won't open their minds.
Anyway, see you tomorrow in Minneapolis! I'll be short fake-blond with the pink bangs, probably somewhere in the back. XD
Amen!
Amen, John. As another Christian who's sometimes a little reluctant to claim the title after watching others drag it through the mud, I ditto everything you say here. And, while obviously you make a great YA author, I think you would have made just as good a minister, and Christianity needs more ministers of your type right now.
Ditto.
Jack i want to pwn them too! I hate them twisters of religion! We are one of a kind! It is truly amazing! Very sick! And Jonny boy cant wait to meet u!!!
My name is Kay and I am going to meet u in a workshop in Berlin soon!!! Write me: skeletor123@hotmail.com
Look at me naked on youtube. giving up a passion is title of video!
Thank you for explaining everything I want to tell people about my faith far better than I have been able to. It's time for moderates to reclaim our faith.
I agree... man, just when we didn't think it was possible, you keep becoming more awesome.
We need this type of conversation, and you discuss it intelligently and thoughfully.
thoughtfully*
John,
That was great. I often wondered about your faith and your take on some of those issues. You've mentioned here and there your work as a chaplain and the oh so cryptic "good Friday, heathen Friday" joke early on in Brotherhood 2.0. Thanks for answering (some) of my questions, and for presenting such a great argument for Christians.
Well said.
I am British, about four years ago when I was young and way too deep into the myth of myself I didn't care if Bush got back in. Now I am incredibly worried that the Republicans may remain in power.
Rational, eloquent stuff like this, gives me hope.
Also glad that finally someone is putting the candidates as supporting God and not God as supporting candidates - He is not a democrat and He is not a republican
Excellent post, John. I always knew I liked you. :)
This goes along with my mantra. Do you want to know what my mantra is? Of course you do! (heh)
People, use your brains!
That's it.
Yeah, it's pretty simple. And maybe dangerous, right? What if people use their brains and come to different conclusions than I do? Well, then, yay! I welcome the chance to look at other people's thought processes and see what sort of arguments they come up with because often I LEARN SOMETHING.
In the midst of financial crises, environmental devastation, and rapid spewing of "doctrine" by both parties, I've found myself very frustrated lately with the reluctance of people to stop and think. It makes me sad. God gave us stewardship of the earth (YES THANK YOU FOR POINTING THAT OUT!) and he also gave us brains. To use.
(I was studying the brain last night - brains are terribly interesting, methinks.)
I am delighted that you expressed yourself so well, and that you once again confirmed yourself as the kind of thinker I enjoy. Thank you.
And...
PEOPLE, USE YOUR BRAINS!
(hmmm...I think my mantra needs more kick to it)
Well said.
I thought I was already sure that I would be voting for Barack Obama in this first presidential election that I am able to vote in (I turned 18 5 short months after the last presidential election.) But now after reading your words, I am more sure than ever that he is my choice. I already knew that you were awesome, John, but this is a side of you that many nerdfighters do not often get to see. Thank you so much for everything you do. I often feel the same discomfort about calling myself a Christian when so many "Christians" have given us a bad name, but you have reminded me about what I should be standing for.
-Rachael
PS: I am going to print out your blog post and make my dad read it. I doubt it will convince him, but at least it might help him understand why I am convinced.
BRAVO! Beautifully stated.
Well said, John. I'm an atheist, but the way you talk about your religion, and how it is involved in the upcoming election, makes a lot of sense to me. Thank you for sharing your point of view.
I agree. It's really annoying that people think christian=super conservative, pro-life, sarah palins.
It makes me almost as mad as the "pregnancy counseling center" next to (but not associated with) my church. Makes us seem nutty.
Wow. I loved reading this and I agree 100%.
Can't wait until Columbus, October 20th!
Obama seemed ok to me until I found out he wanted to "desegregate" churches, and other institutions, that accepted financial help from the government. Meaning require them to hire homosexuals, adulters, men, women, blacks, whites, anyone regardless of what their values. Can you imagine? He holds absolutely no religious value.
I'm Catholic and I support McCain. More precisely, I support Palin, but unfortunately she's not on the ballot.
After reading this blog entry, I'm convinced that you are as close to perfect as a human being could ever get. (Obama doesn't count because he's obviously not human--he's the Messiah. Just kidding, haha.)
Thank you for this entry, it's really nice to hear these opinions from someone that I respect so much. Especially in the world we're living in right now, I'm glad that you have the pride in your faith and politics to make your beliefs public. Plus, I totally agree with everything you said, so it was easy to like this blog entry.
Obama '08!
~Kim
P.S. I just finished reading Paper Towns (I don't know if the library where I work was supposed to get it last week, but it did and it was waiting on the hold shelf for me last Wednesday), and I'm in love. I used to marvel at how I couldn't pick a favorite between Alaska and Katherines, because they're both such different books and I love each one so much. Now I can say the same for Paper Towns.
John, I agree with you about the environment. Because God created the environment, we can't destroy it? I believe that God created people, and people can die. We need to take care of this world and all the animals living in it. Nobody knows exactly how God created the universe. I believe in evolution. We might not be descend from apes, but no one was there when all this happened. Part of science is that theories do not become scientific laws. Megan, a commenter, I really agree with. I'm a McCain supporter, but both parties should try to find common ground, and compromise for the nation.
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home