John Green: Author of Paper Towns, An Abundance of Katherines and Looking for Alaska
An Abundance of Katherines Looking for Alaska Paper Towns anagrams famous last words Bio and Contact

Stars

So for those of you who do not devote your every waking hour to the world of book publishing, there are several journals that review books in advance of their publication.* In each issue, these journals give their favorite few titles "starred reviews." (I do not know where this tradition started, but anyway it is nearly** ubiquitous in the world of children's books.)

And although most readers probably don't even know about this weird little publishing tradition of starring certain reviews, it is--as they say--kind of a big deal. It provides, for one thing, a relatively broad (or the broadest we have, anyway) idea of what critics think of a particular title. (So if a book gets five starred reviews, as The Book Thief did, it indicates there is broad agreement that the book is excellent. Which of course it is.)

I have worked as a book reviewer, and still do sometimes, and I think it's important and interesting work. But authors cannot take too much stock in reviews of their own books, because otherwise they will go crazy. I read reviews mostly because I'm interested to see what people respond to and what they find lacking, but I try not to take it personally, good or bad.

All that said: Alaska and Katherines both received three starred reviews in advance of their publication. Word came from Julie today that Paper Towns has just received its fourth star, from the nice people at School Library Journal.

So that is nice, even if it takes five paragraphs to explain why I am happy! (Also: Big congratulations to sometimes sparksflyup commenter Anna Jarzab on the sale of her first novel in a two-book deal to Delacorte!)

* These include, for instance: Booklist, SLJ, Publishers Weekly, Horn Book, The Bulletin for the Center of Children's Books, KLIATT, and VOYA.
**VOYA does not give stars, for instance.

36 Comments:

At September 18, 2008 , Blogger Gabolicious said...

Congratulations!

 
At September 18, 2008 , Blogger Abby said...

Congrats! Can't wait to read it! :)

 
At September 18, 2008 , Blogger Sash said...

Well, congratulations to both of you!

 
At September 18, 2008 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Nice! I guess this is your first 4 star reviewed book then? If it is i hope your happy! It's good you try not to let the reviews get to you. As long as you think you did good is what matters.

 
At September 18, 2008 , Blogger Sara Z. said...

Congratulations!

VOYA in fact does give stars, along with its P/Q rating.

 
At September 18, 2008 , Blogger shann said...

Congratulations John! I truly think Paper Towns is amazing. I can't wait for October when everyone else gets to read it.

 
At September 18, 2008 , Blogger Mandy S. said...

I think it deserves 40. Good work.

 
At September 18, 2008 , Blogger Paul Carpenter said...

I find the random little inside workings of various industries to be fascinating, traditions that don't make much sense are always the best one.

Congratulations on getting four stars :D

 
At September 18, 2008 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

John, congratulations!! This is such awesome and exciting news to hear.
I, along with everyone else, can not wait until I get to read "Paper Towns" next month.

Also, John, if you don't mind answering this question, how does one secure a job reviewing books or working for book magazines such as Booklist, etc.?? I know you did this for a while, and I am kind of interested in this field and it might be something I go into after graduating from college.
If you can shed some light on this, that would be awesome!!!

 
At September 18, 2008 , Blogger Crystal said...

I <3 VOYA.

And excellent job on the four stars!

 
At September 18, 2008 , Blogger ttulizzy said...

Hey congrats! I've pre-ordered a couple of copies for my library...and I didn't wait to see the starred reviews!

Can't wait to read Paper Towns.

 
At September 18, 2008 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Congrats John, it's definitely deserving. I hope Paper Towns hits the bestseller after all that work the nerdfighters put in... and you, of course. LOL

 
At September 18, 2008 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

it will be so awesome when you and e. lockhart will both be speaking at the printz award brunch (it is a brunch, isn't it? i'm pretty sure) and accepting your awards. i hope i can be there, and it isn't invite only. :-\

 
At September 18, 2008 , Blogger Kristina said...

Alaska only got three stars??? Well, Paper Towns must be overly amazing then.

 
At September 18, 2008 , Blogger Stephen said...

i was carrying a copy of "katherines" down state street in downtown chicago and a fundraiser from the ACLU stopped me to ask for money. i said "sorry, not today." he responded, "come on, man..." then he gestured at my book and said, "you know john green would want you to help us out!" the guy might not even know who "john green" is, but...

what do you think of this?

 
At September 18, 2008 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Congratulations!


Is it weird to be THIS happy for an author? Oh well...

 
At September 18, 2008 , Blogger Beth G said...

Wow! That is great!

 
At September 18, 2008 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Congratulations! Not surprising, though. PAPER TOWNS is my favorite John Green so far. : )

 
At September 18, 2008 , Blogger Riona said...

Congratulations!
I can't wait to read it myself. :D

 
At September 18, 2008 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Congratulations! As a librarian, I would have understood if you had said, "Paper Towns got its fourth starred review!" I guess I'm an insider. : ) In any case, well done!

 
At September 18, 2008 , Blogger Khy said...

Paper Towns deserves 7 stars, as does Alaska and Katherines.

 
At September 19, 2008 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Yay, that is so exciting! I am really looking forward to reading your new, wonderful, and absolutely jokes book! :D (does happy dance for John)

 
At September 19, 2008 , Blogger Betina said...

Congratulation!!

Can't wait to read it :) just found out that I have to write to Amazon, to make sure they send it on time, cause I pre-ordered Alan's Youtube-guide at the same time and now it says I won't get my order before end November/start December!
World suck level just increased a bit..

 
At September 19, 2008 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Squeeeeeeeeeee!

But I'm not surprised. :)

 
At September 19, 2008 , Blogger dawnmetcalf said...

CONGRATS!

(Knowing, of course, they are each worth five stars.)

 
At September 19, 2008 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Paper Towns was given 4 and a half stars by the romantic times reviewer. See link:

http://www.romantictimes.com/books_review.php?book=36471

 
At September 19, 2008 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Wow, almost as crafty as Palin's nondenial denial. The nonbragging woo hoo!

Congrats! Can't wait to read it!

 
At September 19, 2008 , Blogger Steve MC said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

 
At September 19, 2008 , Blogger Leah said...

Congratulations John! Now I really can't wait to read it. Alas, I will have to. As I have preordered it on Amazon and live in Australia it will probably arrive smack bang in the middle of my exam period, but I'm sure it'll be worth the wait.

 
At September 19, 2008 , Blogger Steve MC said...

Congrats, John! Starred reviews definitely catch my eye on dust jackets when deciding on a book, so I guess I have no option now but to pre-order.

 
At September 20, 2008 , Blogger Tomara Armstrong said...

That's great! Congratulations!

I hate that you teased me with the first chapter in Abundance of Katherines and I can't read it yet... my OCD is killing me.

I personally get pissed when I read the reviews of books that I have read and loved and they don't have an ample number of stars... communists should NOT be allowed to write reviews :-P

~2

 
At September 20, 2008 , Blogger Beth said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

 
At September 21, 2008 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Four-star authors! May they have as much influence as the generals with the same number of stars.

Congratulations!

 
At September 21, 2008 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Sweet! And well-earned!

 
At September 23, 2008 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Congrats, John.

Currently considering myself lucky to be working at a bookstore and to be able to read a complimentary copy of it at the moment. It deserves the stars.

Great "clues" throughout which I hope some readers decide to investigate for themselves.

I know I'll have a book to recommend for a good while whenever someone asks me the eternal bookstore question: "What have you read good lately?"

 
At September 26, 2008 , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Congrats John! I can't wait till october 16th! And November 9th....cu in Neport News!

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home

website design by silas dilworth. weblog elements provided by blogger.